PATT ITAC Report for Semester 95A Allocations The
individual partner TAGs hold meetings in their respective countries prior to the PATT session to
assess applications from their own country. At these meetings informal numbers of shifts are
nominated for each application in a priority order. The Chairpersons of each TAG bring their
respective lists to the PATT where the ITAC combine the awards, include discussion of the
engineering and commissioning requirements and assess the international applications. The final
allocations of shifts are made by the ITAC.
Applications to be considered
UK status 57
Canadian status 30
Netherlands status 19
International status 10
University of Hawaii 9
TOTAL: 125
The PATT meeting for
semester 95A was held at The Falcon Hotel in Stratford upon Avon, UK on 7th & 8th December
1994. It should be noted that if the PI on an application is a JCMT staff member based in Hilo,
then the application is assessed by the appropriate national TAG. However, by Board rule,
International status is given to any application where the only named collaborator from any partner
country is such a JCMT staff member. International applications are assessed by the Chairpersons of
the national TAGs at the ITAC meeting.
Time Available (in 16-hour nights)
No. of nights in semester 95A 181
Engineering and Commissioning 29
University of Hawaii (10%) 15
Director's discretionary use 4
Available for PATT science: 133
The above table indicates the order in which nights are removed from
the total available for the semester. Semester 95A covers a summer period from 1st February 1995
through 31st July 1995 inclusive.
Awards (in 16-hour nights)
UK status 69.5
Canadian status 31.5
Netherlands status 25.0
International status 7.0
University of Hawaii 15.0
TOTAL allocation: 148.0
The number of successful
applications was 82. For interest, the spread of these applications was 4 solar system, 17 stellar, 27
galactic and 34 extra-galactic. The average length of time awarded per application was 3.3
shifts. For those not familiar with the JCMT Board formula, the total time requested is divided
amongst the PI and collaborators. 50% of the time is awarded to the country paying the salary of the
PI. The remaining 50% is divided equally over ALL investigators (including the PI).
Attribute by JCMT Board formula (in nights)
UK 48.0
Canada 27.0
Netherlands 22.0
International 36.0
The International attribution of nights comes out at 27% of the total allocation.
Further discussion of this percentage is given in a later section. Much time is being awarded to
collaborations between non-partner investigators and members of the partner consortium but
applications wholly from outside the partner countries continue to obtain time. A graph
indicating the instrument distribution by semester since the beginning of JCMT operations is shown
in Figure 1. The reduction in allocation of time for UKT14 is again due to reduced request as
applicants await the arrival of SCUBA to continue their programmes.
Instrument distribution
UKT14 24%
RxA 27%
RxB 26%
RxC 14%
RxG 8%
A graph indicating the instrument distribution by semester since the beginning of JCMT operations is
shown in Figure 1. The reduction in allocation of time for UKT14 is again due to reduced request as
applicants await the arrival of SCUBA to continue their programmes. Long-Term
Status Application L/M/94A/U19, approved for long-term status for three semesters, was
given 3 shifts. This is the final award of time for this project. Application L/M/95A/U22 was
awarded long-term status for 2 semesters with 6 shifts in 95A and a further 6 shifts to be given in
95B. Engineering & Commissioning The engineering & commissioning
time for 95A includes considerable work to improve the surface, measure receiver characterisations
and efficiencies both of which were allocate time in 94B but were subsequently weathered out.
No time has been allocated for commissioning of SCUBA but 10 shifts have been set aside for RxB3.
There are non-standard instrument configurations schedule for 95A (SBI, FTS & RxG2) which
require set-up and calibration time. Observatory Backup Programme The
Observatory Backup (M/94B/I09) continues to have long-term status for semester 95A for CO (2-1)
and 13CO (2-1) mapping of the nominated sources and any others suggested to the ITAC as long as
there is no conflict with future allocations. All partners agreed to use this programme as a 'last
resort' backup when the weather deteriorates sufficiently to prevent observers using their own
allocated backup but not sufficiently to justify closing the observatory. This programme
terminates in semester 95A and must be resubmitted for future semesters. Service
time Allocations for this semester are: CDN = 8 shifts allocated; NL =
3 shifts allocated; UK = 8.25 shifts allocated Changes to Semester
Numbering By the new convention, semesters that run from February through July are
designated as 'A' and those running from August through January as 'B'. These
are to be preceded by the last two digits from the year. Applications for the forth-coming semester
should refer to semester 95B. Redesign of the JCMT Application form A
new design of application for observing time form, more appropriate for the JCMT and which can be
common to the partner countries, has been devised and approved by the PATT. The form consists of
a single double-sided page of questions to which extra pages for scientific case, technical breakdown,
etc. can be attached. Questions specific to a particular country have been allocated their own layout
on a separate page. A copy of the new form is included within this Newsletter and intending
applicants may photocopy the pages and complete them for submission through the usual route. E-
mail versions of the form are available on the World Wide Web JCMT home page and via the
JCMT_INFO fileserver system. I would like to thank Jacques Vallée and Gerald Moriarty-
Schieven for their able assistance with this new layout. International Applications on the
JCMT There has been some concern that those applications that do not contain a member of
the partner consortium and are thus deemed as 'International' have not been receiving equal
treatment through the PATT allocation committees. Prior to the split into national TAGs the
division of applications was made on the basis of the nationality of only the PI. Since the split only
those applications with no collaborators from the partner countries are treated as 'International'.
Thus the number has decreased. Although the allocation procedures have been modified the statistics
show that there has been NO significant decrease in the time awarded to International
proposals (see Figure 2), which has remained between 15% and 20% by JCMT Board formula and
only slightly lower if the original method of accounting by PI is used. National TAGs are not
allocating their full quota of shifts and ITAC members are coming to the PATT meeting with
'reserve' allocations to fill the gaps if any are left after the International allocations have been
made. The success rate of International applications for semester 95A was about the same as for
the various national applications at 40%.
Figures
Graeme Watt (ITAC Technical Secretary) / ROE
|